+--John Jay LIVINGSTON  (16 AUG 1790-30 DEC 1848)
+--Charles Edward LIVINGSTON  (16 JAN 1835-24 DEC 1863)
|  |                 +--Thomas HORTON  (1602-BEF 24 DEC 1640)
|  |              +--Jeremiah HORTON  (1636-18 AUG 1682)
|  |              |  +--Mary ?  (-19 SEP 1683)
|  |           +--Nathaniel HORTON  (05 MAY 1662-10 JUN 1748)
|  |           |  |  +--Nathaniel ELY 
|  |           |  +--Ruth ELY  (-12 OCT 1663)
|  |           |     +--Martha ? 
|  |        +--Nathaniel HORTON  (11 DEC 1695-06 JUN 1790)
|  |        |  |  +--Nathaniel BURT 
|  |        |  +--Sarah BURT  (APR 1675-)
|  |        |     +--Rebecca SIKES 
|  |     +--David HORTON  (14 MAR 1729-)
|  |     |  +--Hannah PARSONS 
|  |  +--Moses HORTON  (07 JAN 1759-)
|  |  |  +--Anna THAYER 
|  +--Naomi HORTON  (25 JAN 1792-10 MAR 1863)
|     |  +--Ashibell ANDERSON 
|     +--Ame ANDERSON  (29 APR 1756-25 JUL 1820)
|        +--Abigail ? 
Volney Lawrence LIVINGSTON  (22 JAN 1859-08 APR 1910)
+--Elizabeth Jane OSBORN  (26 MAY 1836-15 JAN 1920)